In 1969, the cinematic landscape was forever altered by the release of a film that was as gritty as it was poignant. Starring a young Jon Voight and an already rising Dustin Hoffman, Midnight Cowboy ventured into the shadowy corners of New York City to tell a story of human connection that was both raw and revolutionary. Decades later, the film remains a celebrated cult classic, immortalized by Harry Nilsson’s haunting rendition of “Everybody’s Talkin’” and its unflinching look at the “American Dream” from the perspective of those living on its fringes.
However, even a masterpiece—and the only film with an initial adult-only rating to win the Academy Award for Best Picture—is not immune to the occasional technical oversight. From shifting wardrobe colors to unplanned vehicular cameos, the “imperfections” of Midnight Cowboy actually add to its legendary status.
The Genesis of an Unlikely Duo
When Jon Voight landed the role of Joe Buck, he was an newcomer stepping into the boots of a wide-eyed Texan who moves to Manhattan with dreams of becoming a high-end companion to the city’s wealthy elite. Opposite him was Dustin Hoffman, fresh off the success of The Graduate, transforming himself into “Ratso” Rizzo, a sickly, street-smart con artist living in a condemned building.
The film serves as a profound exploration of:
-
The Harsh Reality of Urban Life: Moving beyond the bright lights of Broadway to show the loneliness of the crowded city.
-
Economic Survival: The desperate lengths to which individuals go when they have no safety net.
-
Platonic Intimacy: The deep, brotherly bond that forms between two men who have nothing left but each other.
The industry quickly took note. Midnight Cowboy secured seven Academy Award nominations, eventually taking home the “Big Three”: Best Picture, Best Director (John Schlesinger), and Best Writing (Waldo Salt). Both Voight and Hoffman earned Best Actor nods, marking one of the rare times two leads from the same film competed for the top prize.
The “I’m Walkin’ Here” Legend: A Happy Accident
Perhaps the most famous scene in film history is the moment Joe and Ratso attempt to cross a busy Manhattan street, only to be nearly leveled by a yellow cab. Hoffman’s indignant outburst—“I’m walkin’ here! I’m walkin’ here!”—has been parodied and celebrated for over fifty years.
While the moment perfectly encapsulates the “New York attitude,” it was never actually in the script. In a candid interview with Jake’s Takes, Jon Voight revealed the chaotic reality behind the camera. The production was filming “guerrilla style” on the actual streets of New York, and while someone was supposed to hold traffic, a frustrated cab driver had simply had enough.
“He was waiting there for 10 minutes while we were fooling around, and he had to get his work done. He was a New York cab driver; he didn’t give a damn about a movie being done,” Voight recalled.
As the cab charged across the street, Hoffman didn’t break character for a second. He slammed his hand on the hood of the car and delivered the iconic line. Voight admitted that in that moment, his only thought was to stay in the scene.
“Dusty sees him and hits the thing… he does the whole thing. I see this happening and all I’m saying to myself is, ‘Stay in character, don’t break, this is it.’”
The cabbie’s genuine frustration and the actors’ instinctual reactions created a level of authenticity that no screenwriter could have manufactured.
Notable Bloopers and Continuity Gaps
Even with its Academy Award pedigree, Midnight Cowboy features several technical “bloopers” that eagle-eyed fans have pointed out over the years. These mistakes serve as a reminder of the frantic, low-budget feel of independent filmmaking in the late 60s.
The Color-Shifting Wardrobe
One of the most glaring continuity errors involves Joe Buck’s Western attire. During a sequence in the city, Joe is seen wearing a bright red Western shirt. However, as the camera cuts between different angles and shots, the shirt suddenly appears to be purple. This happens without any narrative explanation of a wardrobe change, only for the garment to return to its original hue later before he eventually discards it during their fateful bus ride toward Florida.
The Magical Hat
Early in the film, as Joe is making his initial trek through the bustling sidewalks of New York, his cowboy hat seems to have a mind of its own. In one shot, the hat is pushed toward the back of his head in a relaxed, casual style. After a quick cut to a different camera angle, the hat is suddenly perched firmly and squarely on top of his head.
Hoffman’s Method: Stones and Beggars
Dustin Hoffman’s dedication to the role of Ratso Rizzo is the stuff of Hollywood legend. To prove he could play a gritty street dweller after his “pretty boy” role in The Graduate, he reportedly met a film executive on a street corner while dressed as a homeless person. He was so convincing in his request for spare change that the executive didn’t recognize him, proving he had the “chameleon” ability required for the part.
To maintain Ratso’s signature limp throughout long filming days, Hoffman employed a clever, if painful, trick: he placed small stones in his shoe. This ensured that every step he took looked genuinely labored and pained, providing a physical consistency that helped define the character’s deteriorating health.
The Final Scene: A Living “Spirit”
Warning: Spoilers Ahead.
The ending of Midnight Cowboy is widely regarded as one of the most heartbreaking finales in cinema. As Joe and a dying Ratso ride a bus toward the warmth of Florida, Ratso finally succumbs to his illness. In the final moments, Joe realizes his friend is gone and quietly closes his eyes.
However, if you watch closely during this high-definition era, the physical reality of filming becomes apparent:
-
The Flinch: As Jon Voight reaches down to close Ratso’s eyes, Dustin Hoffman’s left eyelid can be seen visibly flinching or twitching slightly upon contact.
-
The Breath of Life: In several frames after the character has supposedly passed away, the slight rise and fall of Hoffman’s chest can be observed, indicating that the “deceased” character was still breathing faintly during the long take.
Despite these minor biological giveaways, the emotional weight of the scene is so immense that most viewers never notice. The chemistry between the two actors is so powerful that the “mistake” of being alive only serves to highlight how much life Hoffman brought to a character who had so little.
The Legacy of Midnight Cowboy
Beyond the technical errors and the unscripted moments, Midnight Cowboy remains a vital piece of film history. It was a movie that refused to look away from the “unpleasant” parts of society, choosing instead to find beauty in the bond between two men who had been discarded by the world.
Whether it is the “I’m walkin’ here” improvisation or the grit of the 1960s New York streets, the film captures a specific moment in time when cinema was becoming more daring and more human. The bloopers don’t detract from the experience; rather, they remind us that the greatest stories are often those that are a little bit messy and entirely real.
If you are a fan of this timeless classic and the incredible performances of Jon Voight and Dustin Hoffman, feel free to share these behind-the-scenes secrets with your fellow film buffs!