RF. Who Will Be the New Duke of York? Expert Weighs In as Prince Andrew Gives Up His Title

The question of who will inherit the title “Duke of York” has resurfaced following reports that Prince Andrew will no longer use his royal titles publicly. While the move has drawn significant public interest, royal experts emphasize that the future of this historic dukedom remains uncertain — and that any formal change would require specific legal and royal procedures.

Prince Andrew Steps Back from Royal Titles

Prince Andrew, the second son of the late Queen Elizabeth II and brother of King Charles III, has officially stepped back from public royal life. This development follows a series of measures taken over recent years to reduce his official presence within the royal family.

Buckingham Palace previously announced in January 2022 that the late Queen had approved the removal of Prince Andrew’s military affiliations and royal patronages, stating that he would “continue not to undertake any public duties.” This change effectively ended his role as a working royal.

Now, under King Charles III’s reign, that process appears to have been completed. According to official royal sources cited by BBC News and The Telegraph, Prince Andrew will no longer use his title of “Duke of York” in an official capacity, though he legally retains it by right of creation.

Prince William, Prince Andrew, and King Charles III during the funeral of Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh at Windsor Castle on April 17, 2021 in Windsor, England. | Source: Getty Images

A Title with Deep Historical Significance

The title Duke of York is one of the most historically significant in the British peerage system. Traditionally, it is granted to the monarch’s second son. It has been held by several notable royal figures, including King George VI before his accession to the throne.

Prince Andrew received the title in 1986 upon his marriage to Sarah Ferguson. The pair later divorced in 1996, though Ferguson continued to be known by the courtesy title “Duchess of York.” However, as reported by Hello! and The Independent, this title is social, not official, and holds no legal standing.

With the recent developments, royal watchers and constitutional experts have been examining what might happen to the Duke of York title next.

Melania Trump, Prince Andrew, Gwendolyn Beck, and Jeffrey Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida, on February 12, 2000 | Source: Getty Images

What Happens to a Dukedom When It Is No Longer Used?

Under current British law, hereditary peerages such as dukedoms cannot simply be removed by royal decree. As constitutional expert Dr. Craig Prescott of Bangor University explains, stripping a royal of a hereditary title would require an act of Parliament, as titles are governed by legal statute.

This means that while Prince Andrew may no longer use the title publicly, it technically still exists under his name until it naturally reverts to the Crown upon his passing.

Prince Andrew and Prince Harry walk behind the coffin during the procession for the Lying-in State of Queen Elizabeth II on September 14, 2022, in London, England. | Source: Getty Images

The Future of the Duke of York Title

Once a dukedom reverts to the Crown, the reigning monarch can choose to reassign it, retire it, or keep it vacant. As The Telegraph reports, no immediate plans have been made regarding the future of the title.

Royal historians note that it is unlikely to be reassigned soon. Traditionally, monarchs have allowed significant time to pass before re-granting titles associated with public controversy. The decision would also depend on the wishes of King Charles III and, in the longer term, Prince William as heir apparent.

Since Prince Andrew has no sons, the title cannot be passed through his direct male line. According to the laws of peerage succession, dukedoms pass only through male heirs unless specifically stated otherwise in their creation. Therefore, Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie are not eligible to inherit it.

When the title does eventually revert to the Crown, King Charles — or his successor — could decide whether to recreate the dukedom for another member of the royal family.

Prince Andrew attends the Sunday Service at the Royal Chapel of All Saints, Windsor, England, on April 11, 2021 | Source: Getty Images

Could Prince Louis Become the Future Duke of York?

Among royal followers, speculation has emerged that Prince Louis, the youngest son of Prince William and Catherine, Princess of Wales, might one day receive the Duke of York title. This idea stems from historical tradition: the title has often been bestowed on the monarch’s second son.

However, this is purely theoretical. As royal experts emphasize, no discussions or decisions about future title assignments have been announced or confirmed by Buckingham Palace.

Prince Louis, who is currently seven years old, remains years away from any formal royal role. His parents, the Prince and Princess of Wales, have consistently expressed their desire to provide their children with a grounded upbringing focused on education and family life before considering official duties.

For now, the title of Duke of York remains legally with Prince Andrew, even if he no longer uses it in public or official settings.

Prince Louis and Prince George during Trooping the Colour in London, England on June 14, 2025. | Source: Getty Images

Sarah Ferguson’s Courtesy Title

As for Sarah Ferguson, she has long been known publicly as the “Duchess of York.” Following her divorce from Prince Andrew, she retained that courtesy style but ceased to use the formal title in official contexts.

According to Town & Country magazine and BBC News, Ferguson continues to be known professionally by her birth name, Sarah Ferguson. She remains an active public figure through her charitable work, writing, and media projects.

Those close to her have indicated that she continues to support the royal family and King Charles’s initiatives. Her daughters, Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie, both remain full members of the royal family and continue to carry out selected charitable engagements.

Prince William and Prince Andrew, Duke of York leave a Service of Thanksgiving for the life and work of Lord Snowdon at Westminster Abbey on April 7, 2017. | Source: Getty Images

Expert Insight: The Symbolism of the King’s Decision

While this development carries no direct constitutional consequences, experts say it reflects King Charles III’s ongoing effort to modernize and streamline the monarchy.

Royal historian Dr. Ed Owens told Sky News that the King’s actions since his accession have shown a clear focus on a “slimmer, more accountable” royal family. By reducing the number of working royals and ensuring that public roles align with the monarchy’s current values, the King is shaping a more contemporary institution.

The decision to remove public use of the Duke of York title aligns with this modernization effort and reinforces the importance of maintaining public trust in the royal institution.

Prince Andrew, Duke of York and King Charles III on September 12, 2022, in Edinburgh, Scotland | Source: Getty Images

What the Future May Hold

At this stage, Buckingham Palace has not issued any statements regarding the reassignment of the Duke of York title. Constitutional experts agree that any change would take place only after the title formally reverts to the Crown.

In theory, a future monarch could grant the title to another royal family member — possibly one of the younger generations — or retire it entirely. There is historical precedent for both actions: some titles have been revived centuries later, while others have been permanently retired.

For now, it appears the title will remain dormant, symbolizing both the end of a chapter and a new era of reform within the British monarchy.

Sarah Ferguson, Duchess of York and Prince Andrew, Duke of York attend Katharine, Duchess of Kent's Requiem Mass service at Westminster Cathedral on September 16, 2025 in London, England. | Source: Getty Images

Conclusion: A Title in Transition

The story of the Duke of York title reflects a broader moment of transition for the royal family. Prince Andrew’s decision to step back from royal life and cease using his title marks the final stage of a long and complex process begun under Queen Elizabeth II.

What happens next — whether the title is reassigned, retired, or remains unused — will ultimately depend on the King’s judgment and the evolving role of the monarchy in modern Britain.

While much public discussion has centered on who might one day inherit the dukedom, official royal sources have made clear that no decisions have been made. For now, the title’s legacy continues quietly, tied to centuries of royal history and awaiting its next chapter.